Monday, February 15, 2010

We Are The World Side By Side

You should judge for yourself, but my comparisons are below.

1985:


2010:




1985

2010

Winner?

Lionel Ritchie

Justin Beiber

1985 because I don’t know this kid and he sounds over-produced

Lionel Ritchie

Nicole Scherzinger

1985

Stevie Wonder

Jennifer Hudson

2010 - more bravado

Paul Simon

Jennifer Nettles

2010 - more umph

Kenny Rogers

Josh Groban

1985 – more country

James Ingram

Tony Bennett

1985 – more soul

Tina Turner

Mary J. Blige

1985, but not by much. I love MJB!

Billy Joel

??

none – Joel doesn’t do it for me and you can’t see his replacement

Michael Jackson

Michael and Janet Jackson

1985 - Janet superimposed is a bit odd

Diana Ross

Barbra Streisand

1985

Dionne Warwick

Miley Cyrus

1985, by a hair. Miley –you’re not bad.

Willie Nelson

Enrique Iglesias

1985 by miles! One of the most disappointing parts of the 2010 song.

Willie Nelson

??

1985 – new people not shown. But no matter what, Willie is amazing here.

Al Jarreau

Jaime Foxx

1985

Bruce Springsteen

Wyclef Jean

1985 but not because Wyclef is bad. Bruce is just a legend in WATH

Kenny Loggins

Adam Levine

2010 – Levine sounds like he could have been in the ’95 video

Steve Perry

Pink

1985, but Pink contends

Daryl Hall

BeBe Winans

2010, but mostly because Hall’s hair is absurd.

MJ

MJ

Tie

Huey Lewis

Usher

1985

Cyndi Lauper

Celine Dion

1985 – no contest

Kim Carnes

Fergie

1985

--

Orianthi (on guitar)

2010, I guess.

Chorus

Nicole Scherzinger, Nick Jonas, Toni Braxton, Mary Mary, Tony Bennett, Isaac Slade

2010 – for the ability to work in more people

Bob Dylan

Lil Wayne

1985 – Say what you want about Dylan, but he doesn’t need Auto Tune.

Chorus

Carlos Santana, Pink, Mary Mary

2010 – if some artists is good, more is better.

Bob Dylan

Akon

1985 – More AutoTune

Chorus

T-Pain

1985 – Do these people ever sing without Auto Tune?

Ray Charles

Jaime Foxx as Ray Charles

1985 because the 2010 version is just embarrassing

No rap in 1985

LL Cool J, Will.i.am, Snoop Dogg, Busta Rymes, Swizz Beatz, Iyaz (why is Jaime Foxx here again)

2010 – I love this part!

Stevie & Bruce

Jennifer Hudson & Mary Mary

1985 – but how can you really compare?

--

Will.i.am & Kanye

2010, despite the controversy

Al Jarreau

Wyclef

2010 – Pretty sweet ending

Chorus Spottings: Dan Akroyd, Tito, Bette Midler, Harry Belefonte, Smokey Robinson,

Jonas Brothers, Gladys Knight, Brian Wilson, a young boy, Vince Vaughn, Randy Jackson, Wilson sisters, Natalie Cole, Faith Evans, Jeff Bridges, Jason Mraz

Both choruses have lots of people I don’t recognize. Toss up.


Winner: 1985. There's a lot of great stuff about the 2010 video, but so many of the new artists can't come close to the original. But, I'm hopeful that in 25 years, I'm going to love this new one.


A Gem:

No comments: