1985:
2010:
1985 | 2010 | Winner? |
Lionel Ritchie | Justin Beiber | 1985 because I don’t know this kid and he sounds over-produced |
Lionel Ritchie | Nicole Scherzinger | 1985 |
Stevie Wonder | Jennifer Hudson | 2010 - more bravado |
Paul Simon | Jennifer Nettles | 2010 - more umph |
Kenny Rogers | Josh Groban | 1985 – more country |
James Ingram | Tony Bennett | 1985 – more soul |
Tina Turner | Mary J. Blige | 1985, but not by much. I love MJB! |
Billy Joel | ?? | none – Joel doesn’t do it for me and you can’t see his replacement |
Michael Jackson | Michael and Janet Jackson | 1985 - Janet superimposed is a bit odd |
Diana Ross | Barbra Streisand | 1985 |
Dionne Warwick | Miley Cyrus | 1985, by a hair. Miley –you’re not bad. |
Willie Nelson | Enrique Iglesias | 1985 by miles! One of the most disappointing parts of the 2010 song. |
Willie Nelson | ?? | 1985 – new people not shown. But no matter what, Willie is amazing here. |
Al Jarreau | Jaime Foxx | 1985 |
Bruce Springsteen | Wyclef Jean | 1985 but not because Wyclef is bad. Bruce is just a legend in WATH |
Kenny Loggins | Adam Levine | 2010 – Levine sounds like he could have been in the ’95 video |
Steve Perry | Pink | 1985, but Pink contends |
Daryl Hall | BeBe Winans | 2010, but mostly because Hall’s hair is absurd. |
MJ | MJ | Tie |
Huey Lewis | Usher | 1985 |
Cyndi Lauper | Celine Dion | 1985 – no contest |
Kim Carnes | Fergie | 1985 |
-- | Orianthi (on guitar) | 2010, I guess. |
Chorus | Nicole Scherzinger, Nick Jonas, Toni Braxton, Mary Mary, Tony Bennett, Isaac Slade | 2010 – for the ability to work in more people |
Bob Dylan | Lil Wayne | 1985 – Say what you want about Dylan, but he doesn’t need Auto Tune. |
Chorus | Carlos Santana, Pink, Mary Mary | 2010 – if some artists is good, more is better. |
Bob Dylan | Akon | 1985 – More AutoTune |
Chorus | T-Pain | 1985 – Do these people ever sing without Auto Tune? |
Ray Charles | Jaime Foxx as Ray Charles | 1985 because the 2010 version is just embarrassing |
No rap in 1985 | LL Cool J, Will.i.am, Snoop Dogg, Busta Rymes, Swizz Beatz, Iyaz (why is Jaime Foxx here again) | 2010 – I love this part! |
Stevie & Bruce | Jennifer Hudson & Mary Mary | 1985 – but how can you really compare? |
-- | Will.i.am & Kanye | 2010, despite the controversy |
Al Jarreau | Wyclef | 2010 – Pretty sweet ending |
Chorus Spottings: Dan Akroyd, Tito, Bette Midler, Harry Belefonte, Smokey Robinson, | Jonas Brothers, Gladys Knight, Brian Wilson, a young boy, Vince Vaughn, Randy Jackson, Wilson sisters, Natalie Cole, Faith Evans, Jeff Bridges, Jason Mraz | Both choruses have lots of people I don’t recognize. Toss up. |
A Gem:
No comments:
Post a Comment